Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Got milk? Chocolate milk ban is positive

Guest Columnist

Published: Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Updated: Wednesday, June 22, 2011 17:06

Last week, the Los Angeles Unified School District banned chocolate milk from its schools' cafeterias. The LA district is the largest to take such a step.

The reason? To combat childhood obesity. And I could not agree more with the decision.

In addition to chocolate milk, the school district also barred chicken nuggets and soda from its menu. According to Matthew Sharp, with the California Food Policy Advocates, by the fall semester, LA Unified School District will be a national leader in a movement toward healthy school cafeterias.

Not everyone is so enthusiastic about the District's decision; the National Dairy Council (NDC) claims that barring chocolate milk from school cafeterias will result in a decrease in milk consumption. They also note that many Americans don't get the USDA's recommended three servings of dairy a day with chocolate milk in cafeterias alone – this move by the LA School District will only do further nutritional harm to our society, rather than good.

It's not surprising the dairy industry would make such statements; its livelihood depends on the consumption of its products. The industry doesn't care about obesity rates in our children – they only care about their profit margins. But the issue of childhood and adult obesity in this society is not a joke; it is an issue of national security.

In September of last year, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates addressed the threat obesity poses to our county. According the an article published in Home Post, Gates told students at Duke University in North Carolina "an ever-growing portion of America's 17-to-24-year-olds – about 75 percent – is simply ineligible or unavailable to serve for a variety of reasons, above all, health and weight requirements in an age of spiraling childhood obesity."

His concerns were an echo of a report released months earlier by former military leaders, titled "Too Fat to Fight." An NPR article summarized the report, stating that "the proportion of recruits rejected for being overweight jumped from 12 percent in 1995 to 21 percent in 2008."

In addition to a threat to national security, childhood obesity also affects our economy and healthcare industry. According to Obesity in America, childhood obesity leads to enormous increases in heart disease, hormonal imbalances, diabetes, physical ailments and heart attacks. Granted, I am not a medical doctor, but I feel these health risks far outweigh the risk of not getting your three daily servings of dairy.

Even the White House has launched a campaign to fight obesity in children. The "Let's Move" campaign, led by first lady Michelle Obama, aims to encourage healthy eating and regular exercise among America's children. Usually, the first lady will tackle literacy rates, or poverty rates, among children. This is the first time the issue of childhood obesity has been taken on – and it's because its effects on this nation's future will be enormous.

That is why childhood obesity must be addressed on the local, state and national level. The dairy industry, the soda industry, the fast-food industry – these businesses will always fight movements toward healthy eating. They want America's children to consume their products. To them, childhood obesity is a sign of success, but the LA School District knows better, as do school districts across the country. We must do what is right for our children, and they cannot fight the food industry alone. Thank you, LA Unified, and I hope more school districts will keep moving forward on these healthy initiatives.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

12 comments

Anonymous
Sun Jun 26 2011 11:14
It's called being a Nanny State you crazy liberal
Anonymous
Fri Jun 24 2011 12:38
Cafeteria food sucks anyways. When I was little I never ate it, my mommy usually gave sammiches and juice boxes and stuff that I brought from home. That was probably much healthier than the reheated frozen slop that the schools were selling in the cafeteria anyways.
Anonymous
Fri Jun 24 2011 12:12
The funny thing is that all these bans will probably have the opposite of their intended effect. If you ban all the food that tastes good from being sold in the cafeteria, then kids will just bring food in their lunchbox that's probably a lot less healthier than milk.
Anonymous
Thu Jun 23 2011 17:45
"Barbarians need laws to regulate their personal behavior; civilized people with self-control do not. "

We're talking about kids here, not adults.

Payne
Thu Jun 23 2011 17:26
We need more laws to protect people from obesity. If we don't make more laws, what will stop me from eating and drinking till arteries my arteries jam?

For Christ's sake, people, it's called responsibility. Barbarians need laws to regulate their personal behavior; civilized people with self-control do not.

GotWater?
Thu Jun 23 2011 15:44
I'm not sure why there are such rabid supporters of milk. I suppose it is a big part of peoples childhood but you have to figure they aren't exactly into the science of it. Milk has tons of added sugar and chemicals. There are better ways to get protein and calcium.
Anonymous
Thu Jun 23 2011 13:21
We are the only mammal that drinks milk after infancy - we don't need to drink milk. It's a myth. Take a vitamin if you're that worried. And I also think we need to consider the amount of carbohydrates in milk - sugar is a carbohydrate, and high even in non-flavored milk. And when you don't exercise, it turns straight to fat. And with more and more state-cuts to education, PE is looking more like a thing of the past. And in regards to exercise, the author also mentions it in her reference to the Let's Move campaign. However it looks like the focus on this article is the banning of chocolate milk, and other unhealthy foods in school cafeterias.
Anonymous
Thu Jun 23 2011 11:01
The solution is to privatize schools
Anonymous
Thu Jun 23 2011 09:17
Chocolate milk ban is negative. We should keep chocolate milk because kids will NEVER drink the fat free milk and the nutritional benefits of milk outweighs the few extra calories from sugar.

Kids need the protein, calcium, and potassium from milk. The government should be trying to get rid of white breads from schools, not milk. For your information, the reason why more people are getting overweight is because people are less active then they used to be and are eating to many carbohydrates from breads.

Anonymous
Thu Jun 23 2011 01:53
"And I could not agree more with the decision."

Of course you do. Because you're a brainless liberal who apparently thinks choice is inherently wrong. I'm glad you found a way to bash those evil corporations though. If nobody keeps them in line then they would get all corporationy. You suck as a human being.

Anonymous
Wed Jun 22 2011 21:53
I do agree that childhood obesity is an issue that we should think about but banning chocolate milk is not the answer, as the person below me stated we should look to diet an exercise. I participated in junior achievement last fall and was somewhat excited to eat a school lunch again. It was pizza with a salad and water. The salad consisted of what looked like artificially grown vegetables with way too much color and an unidentifiable dressing. The pizza was not nearly as good as the square I remember from the days of yore. Healthier options need to be available. By healthier I mean real food not some half-assed lab grown cost efficient slop. At the same time though people should be free to eat what they want. I was fortunate enough to have a home made lunch every day by my mother and understand that not everyone was lucky enough to have that. It included healthy options and not so healthy options with the point being that it was balanced and supported by proper exercise.

As as aside I will say that my oldest brother would wake up every morning and mix 1.5L of milk with what looked like four tablespoons of hershey's chocolate syrup and down it. He did this every morning. It helped that he was captain of the swim team and was active enough to support that diet though.

These days kids are able to opt out of PE and instead of going home and playing outside or gearing up for soccer or baseball practice, they choose to sit down in front of the television and play madden or Call of Duty. This is a consequence of both the times and poor parenting, that more than likely resulted from a line of poor parenting. It isnt very often you see a healthy couple with an obese child.

Wow I just read through this and realize it jumps around quite a bit.

Anonymous
Wed Jun 22 2011 21:18
The solution for childhood obesity is proper exercise, not banning chocolate milk.




log out