Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Improve immigrant policies and rights

Guest Columnist

Published: Monday, September 5, 2011

Updated: Monday, September 5, 2011 19:09

Our immigration system is broken. There's no denying that. I have immigrant friends who can attest to that. Unfortunately, recent steps toward addressing immigration policy have been focused on punishing and deporting immigrants in this nation rather than embracing them.

At the state level, the policies have been extreme and dangerous, such as Arizona's SB 1070, which has been accused of mandating racial profiling. In the last session, the Republican-led Florida Legislature tried to replicate SB 1070 in our state. And at the national level, we have programs such as Secure Communities, which is a program I feel should be removed or drastically reformed.

According to the Los Angeles Times, SComm is a program designed to target and deport "serious convicted criminals," who are also undocumented. Run by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency, the program works with local officials to identify these criminals. The New York Times describes the process, stating fingerprints recorded by state and local police are sent to the Department of Homeland Security, in addition to the FBI. The DHS records immigration policies and can conclude whether an individual booked in jail has also violated immigration laws.

The main objections toward SComm revolve not around its purpose, but its implementation. Most people agree that deporting "serious convicted criminals," such as murderers, rapists and violent criminals is OK. However, and this might come as a shock to some of you, not all illegal immigrants are murderers, rapists or violent criminals. Many of them are actually law-abiding non-citizens. The Huffington Post reports that in the 2010 fiscal year, SComm assisted in the deportation of almost 400,000 people in the United States. Had they all been violent criminals, my view on SComm would be different; however, according to Yahoo! News, about half of those deported had no criminal records aside from civil immigration violations.

Being an illegal immigrant does not make you more likely to commit serious crimes; in fact, according to the Los Angeles Times, studies report that illegal immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than natural-born citizens. Opponents of granting amnesty and implementing immigration reform often dehumanize immigrants, as if they are all violent criminals and a threat to our communities. But what they overlook is the fact that illegal immigrants are part of our community. We are a nation of nations, and lacking proper paperwork does not mean you are not a part of the American community.

The Obama administration has taken a step to signal they agree. On Aug. 18, the administration announced it will review deportations case by case, allowing many undocumented immigrants without criminal records to stay in the U.S. and apply for work permits. Those cases would be considered "low-priority" and would be closed to focus on "high-priority" cases. This change of policy could result in securing thousands of immigrant families, students and future leaders.

But we must remember that not deporting is not the same as granting citizenship. SComm needs to be removed, and the Obama administration needs to continue to act and do all it can through the executive branch to keep moving forward on immigration reform: providing a path to citizenship for illegal – and legal – immigrants. Presently, 11 million immigrants have embraced America, and they deserve to be recognized as such.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

8 comments

Anonymous
Wed Sep 7 2011 22:49
What a travesty of an article. As usual, right off the bat, a person with an ax to grind tries to muddy the waters between "immigrant " and illegal immigrant". They are NOT the same thing, True, the author does indicate that she has a rudimentary understanding of this, but does poorly in illuminating the clear difference. For every immigrant that enters the country illegally (and breaks the law, might I add, something the author swears "immigrants" are not doing - newsflash "law-abiding non-citizens" by its very nature means law-breaking), an immigrant who wants to enter our borders the right, legal way is pushed back by that much more bureaucracy caused by dealing with the vast number of illegals. What's the answer? I agree with the author in that the immigration system, in its current form, is broken and needs reform, but just allowing anyone in that decides to walk over here is NOT the answer. Duh.
Baby Truth
Wed Sep 7 2011 15:18
"I have immigrant friends who can attest to that."

"It's ok, some of my best friends are black."

I wish that the author of this 'article' would respond to some of the intelligent responses on here. It seems to me this piece was not well researched or thought out at all. The editors of this paper should seriously consider never printing her work again.

Anonymous
Wed Sep 7 2011 11:01
I have two friends who legally immigrated to the United States and, as a previous poster commented, it was a difficult, time consuming ordeal, but they felt that to properly be an American, one must go through the proper channels. How can illegal immigrants ever respect or be a part of this country if they have such utter disregard for our laws?
David
Mon Sep 5 2011 22:11
Amnesty was tried in the 1980s and it was a total and complete failure. To try the same exact thing again that has already failed would be beyond foolish.
Anonymous
Mon Sep 5 2011 22:10
Legal resident aliens are law-abiding non-citizens. Illegal aliens are by definition not law-abiding.

Referring to them as law-abiding makes a mockery of all the people who come to America legally and take the time to go through the proper immigration channels.

Anonymous
Mon Sep 5 2011 21:52
SB 1070 specifically prohibits racial profiling. The people who have been saying that it would turn Arizona into a police state are just as ridiculous as the Birthers.
Yo
Mon Sep 5 2011 20:26
We need more European immigrants.
Anonymous
Mon Sep 5 2011 18:04
"lacking proper paperwork does not mean you are not a part of the American community."

Yes it does! What utter nonsense. I am in the process of legally immigrating to the United States. It has taken me years, cost thousands of dollars and there is still no end in sight. The immigration process is unnecessarily onerous but after all I've been through don't you dare tell me that lacking the proper paperwork doesn't matter.

It's no wonder the American public is utterly fed up with illegal immigration and with writers like this one who pander to their cause.





log out