Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

DREAM Act is total nightmare for citizens

Guest Columnist

Published: Saturday, October 15, 2011

Updated: Monday, October 17, 2011 21:10

College students are expected to find their own ways to pay such expenses as housing, tuition, books, a new computer and furniture for the new dorm room, and the list goes on and on.

With a limited chance at getting a major scholarship and the ever decreasing amount of money the federal government supplies to students through grants and loans, at the end of the day, your bank account is left hurting.

Now, thanks to the recently passed DREAM Act (Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors) in California, illegal immigrants are also added as potential recipients to state-funded financial aid and private scholarships.

Is it just me, or is something not right here?

According to the California Student Aid Commission website, 22,569 students received a Cal Grant A and 49,695 students received a Cal Grant B in 2008-2009. Now these same students, in an already highly competitive environment, are going to have to fight with non-American citizens for these federal grants in order to afford attending college.

The California Department of Finance, as reported in an Associated Press article for Fox News online, estimates a total of 2,500, only 1 percent, of accepted university students would now be qualified for aid in California, the costs of which total $14.5 million.

But that's almost 3,000 U.S. born citizens who could be denied aid in California in order to allow illegal immigrants a chance at an education.

As a struggling college student myself, effectively living paycheck-to-paycheck as I make payments to UCF over and over again, I find myself disappointed in California Gov. Jerry Brown and his decision to pass this bill.

Illegal immigrants are just that — illegal. Why should they be guaranteed rights to federal money, as well as in-state tuition for college universities, when I, as a natural-born citizen, can barely afford tuition each semester? The government seems to now be advocating illegal immigration — you jump the border to our country, we'll pay for your college experience.

Back in November 2010, a polling by FAIR (Federation for American Immigration Reform) showed a 54 percent negative response to the, at the time, proposed DREAM Act. Assemblyman Tim Donnelly said in the Fox News online article that the negative response rate is now 80-90 percent of Californians in this month alone.

So, not only is Brown advocating a bill that supports illegal immigration, he's doing it against the majority of Californian popular opinion.

I understand. Illegal immigrants come to America for a chance at a better life. America is a growing power, a technological nation with so many government reforms that make education a key priority in this country.

However, I don't feel that is a valid excuse to enter the country illegally. Go through the legal process of immigration, earn the rights as an American citizen, become educated and have that better life that they most certainly deserve.

I support the 80 percent of Californians against this bill passage. Grant federal aid money to the college students who have gone through the process of legally attending a university. Give privately-funded scholarships and loans to the American citizens who show the most need.

Don't reward students for illegally entering this country with grants and loans they can now qualify for. Don't advocate jumping the border with enticing prospects of a free education. And most certainly don't ignore popular opinion in order to grant "rights" in education to those who have illegally established themselves in this country.

The DREAM Act should have stayed nothing more than a reverie.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

6 comments

Anonymous
Mon Oct 24 2011 12:20
Agree with your opinion whole heartedly. If these minors have anyone to complain to, it's TO their parents. Dont complain to the government; dont expect anything from the government just because your parents decided to do something illegal; dont give me the crap that they will never learn to adjust in their country of origin---everyday people of all ages migrate and re-assimilate themselves in societies they have never known before. The only reason why they want to stay is because despite the illegal action done by their parents, they want to benefit from society. To the dreamers, I have nothing against you. BUT BLAME YOUR PARENTS FIRST AND FOREMOST for the diffculty you are encountering. We all have difficulties---I dont whine and expect the government to help me...
Anonymous
Sun Oct 23 2011 20:39
Let's give even more incentives for illegals to come here!

"You obviously do not understand the most basic points of the DREAM Act. It isn't to "reward students for illegally entering this country...jumping the border...[and] illegally established themselves in this country." Frankly, that is very insulting. Reward students? I would urge you to issue an apology because your "opinion" seems to push the envelope a bit to far with your sharp choice of words. Back to the point though, the DREAM Act is specifically so that we do not punish undocumented immigrants in the United States who may have entered as a baby or a child and had no voice in the actions of their parents. It is so that we encourage them to continue to be active and productive participants of our society. And if you're going to write a serious opinion piece, please, at least find legitimate sources to back your opinions. This means finding concrete information to base your opinions off of, not opinions to base your opinions off of. Have a great day. "

Ali Kurnaz
Sat Oct 22 2011 13:53
You obviously do not understand the most basic points of the DREAM Act. It isn't to "reward students for illegally entering this country...jumping the border...[and] illegally established themselves in this country." Frankly, that is very insulting. Reward students? I would urge you to issue an apology because your "opinion" seems to push the envelope a bit to far with your sharp choice of words. Back to the point though, the DREAM Act is specifically so that we do not punish undocumented immigrants in the United States who may have entered as a baby or a child and had no voice in the actions of their parents. It is so that we encourage them to continue to be active and productive participants of our society. And if you're going to write a serious opinion piece, please, at least find legitimate sources to back your opinions. This means finding concrete information to base your opinions off of, not opinions to base your opinions off of. Have a great day.
Anonymous
Fri Oct 21 2011 11:10
This piece is poorly researched and makes some flat out ignorant statements. I would expect more from our university's newspaper.
Anonymous
Thu Oct 20 2011 21:41
I agree with Aned Ladino, you obviously haven't researched the Dream Act thoroughly enough to write on the matter. And if you want to be have your writing taken seriously, I advise you don't use "You jumped the border." It makes you sound uneducated and racist.
Matthew Robles
Mon Oct 17 2011 12:26
I don't think you do understand. Some of these students come to the U.S. while they were young children. Yet you blame them as if they really had a choice in where to ilegally reside. If they can competitively aquire these federal grants over other Americans, despite language setbacks, then my arguement is that these Americans "denied" the aid don't deserve it. Simply because you are born in a particular place does not mean you deserve these funds anymore then these students do. What you suggest is that Americans were born better and thus deserve these funds. The intelligent should be educated, not simply those with citizenship.




log out