Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Team Potter, forget Edward vs. Jacob

Guest Columnist

Published: Saturday, August 14, 2010

Updated: Monday, August 16, 2010 14:08


Sparkly vampires, teenage romance, Hollywood clichés … gag me.
 
For the past few years, ever since production of the first Twilight movie began, it seems every teenage girl feels the need to ramble on about the book-turned-movie, and quite frankly I'm sick of it.
 
Over this past summer, the pop-culture craze turned into an unhealthy obsession as young girls and their unenthused boyfriends lined up for the movie premiere of Eclipse, bickering over Team Edward versus Team Jacob.
 
Seriously, give me originality and adventure, like in the Harry Potter series, then I'll be happy.
 
Really though, if the Twilight films were just bad movies, I wouldn't complain. Unfortunately, I've had the misfortune of seeing many bad films in my day, but that series has gone way beyond just being bad.
 
The worst part about this whole debacle is that these insane Twilight fanatics think their sorry excuse for a film series is better than the glory that is Harry Potter.
 
Not true at all.
 
Let me start out by constructing a timeline. The first film in the Twilight series barged into theatres in November 2008. Now, only two years later, three of the films have already been released. Luckily, this means there is only one more film left to go.
 
The first Harry Potter graced the big screen in November 2001, and today, almost nine years later, six of the seven books in the series have been released as movies.
 
What's remarkable about this set of facts is that over nine years, the popularity of the Harry Potter series hasn't died down. Movie goers still line up on opening night covered in cloaks and flicking wands.
 
Stephenie Meyer, on the other hand, knew that she could only profit for so long before the nation's teeny boppers and lonely housewives found some other trend to lap up.
 
When the first Twilight movie came out, I figured that although the concept may have seemed a bit corny and over sensationalized, the movie would most likely have some awesome special effects and be a cinematic work of art.
 
Boy was I wrong.
 
The execution of the film was entirely lackluster, from the awkward camera angles to the unconvincing acting.
 
Last time I checked, flipping your hair and biting your lip didn't qualify you for an Oscar.
 
Every time I watch any one of the Harry Potter films (yes, I've seen them all countless times), it truly is an inspiring experience.
 
J.K. Rowling created an entire world of magic and fantasy, and with the help of various directors, she managed to translate that world from paper to film flawlessly.
 
She gives us a whimsical castle, moving staircases, a shrieking shack and an enchanted forest, and that's just scratching the surface.
 
In fact, Rowling gives us so much imagery and creativity that Universal Studios was able to construct an entire theme park, based solely on the series.
 
Let's see them try to make a theme park centered on "Edward's perfect face."
 
Finally, there are the characters. Twilight gives us a male-dependent young girl with absolutely no personality, a sorry excuse for a vampire with stalker tendencies and a werewolf who can't seem to take a hint.
 
May I also add that I find none of these characters physically attractive.
 
In Harry Potter, each of the main characters is courageous, loyal, out to protect the wizarding world, kept strong by the bonds of their friendship.
 
My point with all of this is that it's fine if you like Twilight, to each his own, right?

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

4 comments

Anonymous
Mon Aug 16 2010 01:27
I completely agree. The only thing Twilight is good for is the nerimon videos on youtube. search "Alex reads Twilight"
Alyssa
Sun Aug 15 2010 21:51
This is so correct. Harry Potter is about morals, bravery, friendship, and love. I seriously can't understand any morals that might be in any Twilight book or film. When I read the Twilight books, I seriously thought that there were ok and an entertaining story, but it is defently not worth all the hype. Plus, they destroyed all the coolness associated with vampires. Give it three more years, and no one will care. Harry Potter will live forever.
Luisa
Sun Aug 15 2010 21:34
This is really good. You're absolutly right, but come on! say this today is just suicide. A mlot of little girls would die if they read this, but let's be honest, I don't believe they would read it, I've discovered that Twilight Fans don't read to much. XD. (I'm sorry if i got any grammar mistake, english is not my language)
Mishpot
Sun Aug 15 2010 20:50
Agreed 100% with everyhting you mentioned. I mean just ask a HP or Twilight fan why they think their preferred series (book and/or movies) is superior to the other one.

HP fan will mention or at least touch on the points you described above.

Twilight fan will say something like: 'Twilight is the best. Harry Potter sucks...' and when you ask for reasons they will repeat that over and over again without actually having any reasons at all.

That shows how much Twilight's popularity is due to a short term hype, which i'm sure will end as soon as the last film comes out. Harry Potter Fandom will exist for quite a while after the last movie just because of all the fansites, the podcasts, the book forum discussions: all of those show the depth of the world created by JK Rowling.

Not to offend any of the Twilight fans, which opinions and interests I respect, but I compare Twilight to a stain on HP's shirt, that is a bit hard to wash out, but which is fading away pretty fast after every wash XD.







log out